Hollywood is recession-proof, the old adage goes. But
industry insiders are not convinced by the conventional wisdom
that the Great Depression was a golden age for film-making, and
they are even less sure it will emerge from the current
recession unscathed. This year, studio executives are facing up
to the reality of slashing jobs, dropping risky projects and an
increased struggle to raise finance.
Britain and the US are officially in recession, yet in the past
the cinema has avoided the worst economic disintegration. This
time round, box-office spending has remained flat for three
years and, according to accountants at Deloitte, "the movie
theatre is likely to face some of the toughest trading
conditions in years during 2009".
Kurt Scherf, an analyst at Parks Associates, said: "The studios
are suffering the same issues as everyone else. It is
frightening to see what is happening. It all depends on consumer
spending and at the moment the wallets are slammed shut. There
is no way cinema will avoid this impact."
General Electric, which owns the media and entertainment giant
NBC Universal, announced on Monday that its profits had plunged
44 per cent in the last quarter of the year. This followed news
it is shedding 7,000 staff to save $2bn (£1.4bn), with cuts
likely at its NBC network. It is by no means alone.
Hollywood is often perceived as a dream factory insulated from
the wider world's problems, but these days all the major studios
are part of diversified multinational corporations, which have
felt the economic chill in other parts of their businesses.
Michael Gubbins, the editor of the film industry journal Screen
International, said the attitude of studios towards new projects
was changing dramatically. "They are now concentrating on
film-making for profit. Historically, that hasn't been such a
focus. It is getting tougher out there." GE's announcement came
shortly after Warner Brothers, which made last year's Batman
blockbuster The Dark Knight, said it would cut about 800 staff,
or 10 per cent of its workforce, in response to the
disintegrating market. Executives at its parent company, Time
Warner, said: "Based on the global economic situation and
current business forecasts, the studio will have to make staff
reductions in the coming weeks in order to control costs."
Barry Meyer, the Time Warner chairman and chief executive,
added: "The changing entertainment business landscape, shifting
consumer demand and the overall state of the economy have
affected companies around the world, and Warner Brothers is not
immune to these factors."
Paramount, owned by Viacom, announced 150 job cuts last month,
while the problems at Sony Pictures' parent company continue to
mount. On Thursday, Sony forecast annual losses of Y150bn
(£1.2bn), which followed news that it would lay off 8,000
workers in its electronics business. The studio is likely to
suffer in the coming months.
Mr Gubbins said: "Faced with economic realities, the studios
have to look at the mundane things of running a business, such
as staffing levels."
Cinema admissions are expected to fall as film fans stay at
home, content to watch television or play computer games.
Indeed, game sales soared by 40 per cent in the US last year,
and Mr Scherf also predicts an increase in video-on-demand
services from providers such as Virgin Media and BT.
DVD sales are also beginning to slow. Ann Daly, the chief
operating officer of DreamWorks Animation, admitted last month:
"The home video market is maturing and has recently been hurt by
the economic downturn. The current recession and lack of
consumer spending domestically are having a dramatic impact."
As a result, film companies are dropping expensive projects. The
number of movies released by Warner Brothers fell from a peak of
40 per year to 25 in 2008. Last month, Walt Disney Pictures
withdrew its backing for the third Chronicles Of Narnia film,
The Voyage Of the Dawn Treader, citing "budgetary and logistical
reasons". The production remains in limbo, even though Disney's
first Narnia film made $745m and the second, Prince Caspian,
earned $420m worldwide. "Studios are now focusing on fewer
franchises that they believe will make money," Mr Gubbins said.
"Companies are taking very hard-headed financial decisions."
Disney makes the popular Pirates Of The Caribbean and High
School Musical series, while Warner has Batman and Harry Potter.
As the credit crisis has intensified, so financing options have
weakened. Banks are refusing to lend on anything but safe
options, which is bad news for independent film-makers. Warner,
which has forecast its first annual loss for six years, has
already shut Warner Independent Pictures and Picturehouse, and
brought New Line Cinema in-house.
In recent years, hedge funds have invested $12bn in movies. The
fourth film in the Terminator franchise, Terminator Salvation,
starring Christian Bale and due for release this year, was
backed by hedge fund money, but the well appears to be running
dry.
"The banks aren't lending, while hedge funds and the
multi-billionaires who fancied operating in the movie world has
slowed," Mr Gubbins said.
He predicted that the industry could polarise to mega-budget
franchise films and micro-budget independent features.
Mr Gubbins said: "There will be more cuts and, added to the
prospect of an actors' strike around the corner, there could be
a perfect storm brewing for the studios. It is a period of
change and real consolidation around a tough business. It is a
very precarious time."
So what has changed since 1929? The Great Depression did see
American audiences flocking to the pictures, driven by the
novelty of talking films, a desire for escapism and the scarcity
of televisions at home.
But by 1933, as unemployment soared, cinema attendances had
fallen by 40 per cent. One industry source said: "It was a bit
of a myth that cinema did really well out of the Depression.
Theatres were closing down the whole time. People stopped
going."
|